Schedule Tour
$1,999,000

2 Penny Ln

Nissequogue, NY
Pending
5
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
4,929
Square Feet
1.0
Lot Size (acres)
1997
Year Built
67
Days On Market

Waterfront on the Long Island Sound, this rare offering features 75 feet of direct frontage and is set on a beautifully landscaped acre at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac within a private beach community. An entertainer’s dream, the property features a stunning bluestone patio overlooking the water, complete with a gazebo and generous seating areas—all positioned to take in expansive views of the Sound and spectacular sunsets. The perfect setting for hosting summer BBQs or simply relaxing and unwinding in your own waterfront oasis. Private steps lead directly to the beach and water below, creating an exceptional setting for outdoor dining, entertaining or simply enjoying the waterfront. The traditional 5-bedroom, 3-full-bath Center Hall Colonial features spacious formal rooms, wood floors and an impressive formal entry hall with soaring ceilings and a custom bridal staircase. The eat-in kitchen features white cabinetry, granite countertops, a center island with seating and a large dinette area, and opens directly to the beautiful great room with soaring ceilings, a wood-burning fireplace and large windows that bring the beauty of the surrounding landscape indoors. Glass sliders open to a large entertainment deck, extending the living space outdoors. A first-floor bedroom, equally well suited as a home office, and conveniently located laundry add flexibility to the main level. The second-floor primary suite offers a private retreat with beautiful views of the Long Island Sound, an electric fireplace and two walk-in closets. The spacious ensuite bath features double sinks and a Jacuzzi tub positioned beneath a wall of windows, creating a peaceful place to relax while taking in the water views. Three additional generously sized bedrooms, a spacious main full bath with double sinks, and a private outdoor deck complete the second floor. A full basement offers substantial additional space and storage with the potential to be finished in the future, while the 3-car garage with a car lift provides added versatility. Professionally landscaped grounds are enhanced by landscape lighting, a hot tub, generous driveway parking and multiple outdoor spaces for dining, gathering and relaxing by the water. With the Long Island Sound just beyond the backyard, private beach access and gorgeous sunsets unfolding across the horizon, the setting offers the feeling of being on vacation year-round, all from the privacy of your own home.

Take the 3D virtual tour →

Listing Information

Listing Updated
29 days ago
Listed By
Bonnie Glenn · Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, 6315846600
MLS#
1038110
Source
OneKey MLS
Status
Pending

Facts & Features

Location

Community Information

Address
2 Penny Ln, Nissequogue, NY 11780
City
Nissequogue
County
Suffolk
Neighborhood
'The Dunes at Nissequogue"
Zip Code
11780

Architecture

Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
3
Year Built
1997
Style
Colonial
Construction Materials
Frame, Vinyl Siding
Building Area
4,929 sq. ft.
Garage
Yes
Garage Spaces
3
Parking Features
Driveway, Garage

Features & Amenities

Interior Features
High Speed Internet, Ceiling Fan(s), Cathedral Ceiling(s), Eat-in Kitchen, Walk-In Closet(s), Pantry, Kitchen Island, Storage, Granite Counters, Double Vanity, Recessed Lighting, High Ceilings, Entrance Foyer, Crown Molding, His and Hers Closets, Chandelier
Appliances
Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer, Convection Oven, Electric Oven, Exhaust Fan, Electric Cooktop
Flooring
Hardwood, Tile, Carpet
Exterior Features
Lighting, Rain Gutters
Patio and Porch
Patio, Deck
Cooling
Central Air
Heating
Baseboard, Hot Water, Oil

Property Features

Lot Size
1 Acres
Lot Features
Waterfront, Cul-De-Sac, Private, Landscaped, Sprinklers In Front, Sprinklers In Rear, Back Yard, Front Yard
View
Water
Water
Public
Sewer
Septic Tank
Utilities
Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Water Connected, Underground Utilities

Square Footage

Total
3,754 sq. ft.

Tax & Financial Information

List Price
$1,999,000
Annual Taxes
$35,788
Association Fee
$500 (paid Annually)
Fee Includes
Snow Removal

Schools

53/100
Nesaquake Middle School
Middle · Grades 06–08 · 3.6 mi
Assigned school for this home
City
Saint James
Students
473
Student body
82% White · 8% Hispanic / Latino · 6% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
10%
Phone
(631) 382-5105
100/100
Mills Pond Elementary School
Elementary · Grades KG–05 · 3.5 mi
City
Saint James
Students
445
Student body
82% White · 8% Asian · 7% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
8%
Phone
(631) 382-4305
99/100
Nassakeag Elementary School
Elementary · Grades PK–06 · 2.9 mi
City
East Setauket
Students
522
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
76% White · 12% Asian · 9% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
4%
Phone
(631) 730-4400
77/100
Paul J Gelinas Junior High School
Middle · Grades 07–09 · 2.3 mi
City
Setauket
Students
647
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
75% White · 11% Asian · 8% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
9%
Phone
(631) 730-4700
77/100
Robert Cushman Murphy Junior High School
Middle · Grades 07–09 · 3.3 mi
City
Stony Brook
Students
698
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
66% White · 18% Asian · 11% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
16%
Phone
(631) 730-4800
59/100
Dogwood Elementary School
Elementary · Grades KG–05 · 4.6 mi
City
Smithtown
Students
350
Student–teacher
12.5
Student body
80% White · 13% Hispanic / Latino · 3% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
13%
Phone
(631) 382-4255
56/100
William Sidney Mount Elementary School
Elementary · Grades PK–06 · 2.5 mi
City
Stony Brook
Students
525
Student body
55% White · 24% Asian · 14% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
20%
Phone
(631) 730-4300
55/100
Setauket Elementary School
Elementary · Grades PK–06 · 3 mi
City
Setauket
Students
559
Student body
83% White · 7% Hispanic / Latino · 5% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
9%
Phone
(631) 730-4600

School ratings are provided for informational purposes only and are subject to change. Attendance boundaries are for reference only — contact the school or district directly to verify enrollment eligibility.

Historical Data

Price History

DateEventPrice
08/12/2026Listed for sale$1,999,000

Listed by Bonnie Glenn · Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty · 6315846600

Listing information provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed by the MLS. The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed. Copyright 2026, OneKey MLS. All rights reserved.

Last Updated: September 18, 2026 at 8:03 PM | Source: OneKey MLS | MLS#: 1038110

Let's work together

Start Your Real Estate Journey

Whether you have questions about this listing, want to schedule a showing, or just want to talk through your options, James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.

How can I help?

James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.

Lending calculator

Make A Plan For Your Purchase

Know what you can afford before you start shopping — then run the numbers on any home you have in mind.

How much house can I afford?

$500,000
You can afford
$0
Monthly payment
  • Principal & interest
  • Property taxes
  • Homeowner's insurance
  • HOA dues

Enter your income, debts, and down payment to see how much home you may qualify for. Estimates only — not a lending decision.

Want to know more?

James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.