Schedule Tour
$759,000

40 Christian Ave

Setauket, NY
Active
4
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
1.23
Lot Size (acres)
1920
Year Built
45
Days On Market

Welcome to 40 Christian Ave in historic Setauket! Set on a rare, oversized 1.23-acre lot in the Three Village School District, this newly renovated home offers exceptional space, flexibility and possibilities for today’s buyers. The home features 3-4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, which includes a fully finished basement, and an exceptionally versatile layout. A standout feature is the home’s three separate entry points and large off-street parking area, giving buyers the flexibility to configure and enjoy the space according to their individual needs—whether for extended living, guests, a home office, recreation, or additional private space. Recent improvements include upgraded 200-amp electrical service and a re-conditioned driveway, complementing the home’s extensive renovation and making it ready for its next chapter. The generous 1.23-acre property provides plenty of outdoor space and privacy while offering the flexibility that is increasingly hard to find in Setauket. Conveniently located near north of 25A,Stony Brook University, West Meadow Beach, shopping ,Walk to Setauket school, Duck Pond and historic charm of the Three Village area. With three separate entrances, flexible interior spaces, a finished basement and an oversized lot, Low taxes . this property offers buyers the opportunity to make the home work around their lifestyle and needs! SOLD AS IS .

Listing Information

Listing Updated
25 days ago
Listed By
Yan Zhang · E Realty International Corp, 7188868110
MLS#
1045776
Source
OneKey MLS
Status
Active

Facts & Features

Location

Community Information

Address
40 Christian Ave, Setauket, NY 11733
City
Setauket
County
Suffolk
Zip Code
11733

Architecture

Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
3
Year Built
1920
Style
Exp Ranch
Construction Materials
Brick
Garage Spaces
0
Parking Features
Driveway

Features & Amenities

Interior Features
Eat-in Kitchen, Kitchen Island, Entrance Foyer
Appliances
Dryer, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Washer, Gas Cooktop, Cooktop, Oven, Gas Oven
Cooling
Multi Units
Heating
Oil

Property Features

Lot Size
1.23 Acres
Lot Features
Back Yard, Front Yard, Near Public Transit, Paved
Water
Public
Sewer
Cesspool
Utilities
Cable Available

Square Footage

Total
1,535 sq. ft.

Tax & Financial Information

List Price
$759,000
Annual Taxes
$3,560

Schools

55/100
Setauket Elementary School
Elementary · Grades PK–06 · 0.7 mi
Assigned school for this home
City
Setauket
Students
559
Student body
83% White · 7% Hispanic / Latino · 5% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
9%
Phone
(631) 730-4600
75/100
Paul J Gelinas Junior High School
Middle · Grades 07–09 · 0.2 mi
Assigned school for this home
City
Setauket
Students
647
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
75% White · 11% Asian · 8% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
9%
Phone
(631) 730-4700
49/100
Ward Melville Senior High School
High · Grades 09–12 · 3 mi
Assigned school for this home
City
East Setauket
Students
1,688
Parent reviews
1.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
84% White · 9% Asian · 4% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
11%
Phone
(631) 730-4900
100/100
Nassakeag Elementary School
Elementary · Grades PK–06 · 2.2 mi
City
East Setauket
Students
522
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
76% White · 12% Asian · 9% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
4%
Phone
(631) 730-4400
77/100
Robert Cushman Murphy Junior High School
Middle · Grades 07–09 · 3.3 mi
City
Stony Brook
Students
698
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
66% White · 18% Asian · 11% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
16%
Phone
(631) 730-4800
74/100
Earl L Vandermeulen High School
High · Grades 09–12 · 2.7 mi
City
Port Jefferson
Students
357
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
81% White · 8% Asian · 7% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
6%
Phone
(631) 791-4421
74/100
Arrowhead Elementary School
Elementary · Grades PK–06 · 3.5 mi
City
East Setauket
Students
574
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
68% White · 14% Asian · 11% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
17%
Phone
(631) 730-4100
57/100
William Sidney Mount Elementary School
Elementary · Grades PK–06 · 3.4 mi
City
Stony Brook
Students
525
Student body
55% White · 24% Asian · 14% Hispanic / Latino
Free/reduced lunch
20%
Phone
(631) 730-4300

School ratings are provided for informational purposes only and are subject to change. Attendance boundaries are for reference only — contact the school or district directly to verify enrollment eligibility.

Historical Data

Price History

DateEventPrice
09/15/2026Price change$759,000
09/03/2026Listed for sale$799,000

Listed by Yan Zhang · E Realty International Corp · 7188868110

Listing information provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed by the MLS. The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed. Copyright 2026, OneKey MLS. All rights reserved.

Last Updated: September 22, 2026 at 6:37 PM | Source: OneKey MLS | MLS#: 1045776

Let's work together

Start Your Real Estate Journey

Whether you have questions about this listing, want to schedule a showing, or just want to talk through your options, James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.

How can I help?

James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.

Lending calculator

Make A Plan For Your Purchase

Know what you can afford before you start shopping — then run the numbers on any home you have in mind.

How much house can I afford?

$500,000
You can afford
$0
Monthly payment
  • Principal & interest
  • Property taxes
  • Homeowner's insurance
  • HOA dues

Enter your income, debts, and down payment to see how much home you may qualify for. Estimates only — not a lending decision.

Want to know more?

James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.