Schedule Tour
$750,000

17 Fenwick Ave

Farmingville, NY
Active
5
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
0.37
Lot Size (acres)
1972
Year Built
32
Days On Market

Discover this unique and versatile 5-bedroom, 3-full-bath Contemporary Cape Cod, offering approximately 2900 square feet of living space on a beautifully situated lot. Extension added in 2003, this home offers endless possibilities. The accessible extension features its own private entrance, bathroom, walk-in closet, cathedral ceilings, skylights, recessed lighting, and an abundance of natural sunlight. With its versatile layout, this space can also serve as a luxurious first-floor primary suite, private guest quarters, bonus room or a comfortable living area for a caregiver. Even extra income with proper permit. The main home offers a bright and welcoming kitchen with sliding glass doors leading to a large patio, perfect for outdoor dining and entertaining. The adjacent dining and living areas feature cathedral ceilings, large windows, and an abundance of natural light. The first-floor primary bedroom includes its own sliding glass door leading to a private patio. Enjoy the comfort of oil baseboard heating, three wall-mounted AC units, and 200-amp electrical service. The home also features vinyl siding, newer windows upstairs, eight-year-old kitchen floor, washer and dryer, 10 closets and leased solar panels installed in 2015. Step outside to your private backyard, complete with an in-ground sprinkler system, two sheds, partial newer fence, and plenty of room to create your own outdoor oasis. Security cameras provide added peace of mind. Additional parking is available across the street, and the property offers the potential to build to suit. Located in a welcoming, friendly neighborhood known for its walkers, bike riders, and community park, this property combines space, flexibility, and convenience. Whether you’re looking for a home to accommodate a growing family, extended family, or unique living arrangements, this versatile property offers incredible potential. Near Long Island Expressway, Nicolls Rd and shopping! Come explore all that this special home has to offer!

Listing Information

Listing Updated
2 days ago
Listed By
Michele L. Mullady · Exit Realty Island Elite, 6313314000
MLS#
1051639
Source
OneKey MLS
Status
Active

Open Houses

  • Sunday, October 18
    12:00 PM – 2:00 PM

Facts & Features

Location

Community Information

Address
17 Fenwick Ave, Farmingville, NY 11738
City
Farmingville
County
Suffolk
Neighborhood
Birchwood North Shore
Zip Code
11738

Architecture

Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
3
Year Built
1972
Style
A-Frame
Construction Materials
Vinyl Siding
Garage Spaces
0
Parking Features
Driveway, On Street

Features & Amenities

Interior Features
Cathedral Ceiling(s), Walk-In Closet(s), Storage, Recessed Lighting
Appliances
Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Oven
Cooling
Wall/Window Unit(s)
Heating
Baseboard, Oil

Property Features

Lot Size
0.37 Acres
Water
Public
Sewer
Public Sewer
Utilities
Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected

Square Footage

Total
2,900 sq. ft.

Tax & Financial Information

List Price
$750,000
Annual Taxes
$11,112

Schools

74/100
Chippewa Elementary School
Elementary · Grades KG–05 · 0.4 mi
Assigned school for this home
City
Holtsville
Students
549
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
65% White · 22% Hispanic / Latino · 5% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
24%
Phone
(631) 696-8640
53/100
Sagamore Middle School
Middle · Grades 06–08 · 0.2 mi
Assigned school for this home
City
Holtsville
Students
898
Student body
59% White · 28% Hispanic / Latino · 6% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
35%
Phone
(631) 696-8600
100/100
Merrimac School
Elementary · Grades KG–05 · 2.7 mi
City
Holbrook
Students
414
Student body
76% White · 12% Hispanic / Latino · 6% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
13%
Phone
(631) 244-5670
75/100
Waverly Avenue School
Elementary · Grades KG–05 · 0.9 mi
City
Holtsville
Students
470
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
61% White · 24% Hispanic / Latino · 6% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
32%
Phone
(631) 654-8690
59/100
Lynwood Avenue School
Elementary · Grades KG–05 · 1.6 mi
City
Farmingville
Students
562
Parent reviews
3.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
59% White · 27% Hispanic / Latino · 5% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
29%
Phone
(631) 696-8650
54/100
Nokomis School
Elementary · Grades KG–05 · 1 mi
City
Holbrook
Students
520
Student body
60% White · 27% Hispanic / Latino · 6% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
24%
Phone
(631) 471-1840
54/100
Tamarac Elementary School
Elementary · Grades KG–05 · 1.8 mi
City
Holbrook
Students
461
Student body
76% White · 15% Hispanic / Latino · 4% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
20%
Phone
(631) 244-5680
54/100
Seneca Middle School
Middle · Grades 06–08 · 1.7 mi
City
Holbrook
Students
1,038
Student body
72% White · 17% Hispanic / Latino · 4% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
21%
Phone
(631) 471-1850

School ratings are provided for informational purposes only and are subject to change. Attendance boundaries are for reference only — contact the school or district directly to verify enrollment eligibility.

Historical Data

Price History

DateEventPrice
09/16/2026Listed for sale$750,000

Listed by Michele L. Mullady · Exit Realty Island Elite · 6313314000

Listing information provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed by the MLS. The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed. Copyright 2026, OneKey MLS. All rights reserved.

Last Updated: October 15, 2026 at 11:14 PM | Source: OneKey MLS | MLS#: 1051639

Let's work together

Start Your Real Estate Journey

Whether you have questions about this listing, want to schedule a showing, or just want to talk through your options, James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.

How can I help?

James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.

Lending calculator

Make A Plan For Your Purchase

Know what you can afford before you start shopping — then run the numbers on any home you have in mind.

How much house can I afford?

$500,000
You can afford
$0
Monthly payment
  • Principal & interest
  • Property taxes
  • Homeowner's insurance
  • HOA dues

Enter your income, debts, and down payment to see how much home you may qualify for. Estimates only — not a lending decision.

Want to know more?

James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.