Schedule Tour
$640,000

26 Garfield Ave

East Islip, NY
Active
2
Bedrooms
1
Bathrooms
1,320
Square Feet
0.34
Lot Size (acres)
1920
Year Built
172
Days On Market

Opportunity Knocks at 26 Garfield Ave! Historic Charm + Massive Potential Discover this charming 1 and 1/2 story 2-bedroom, 1-bath 1920's Vintage cottage situated on a beautiful .34 flat treed lot in a highly sought-after East Islip neighborhood. Perfect for first-time homebuyers, investors or anyone looking to create their dream space. Property Highlights: Historic Charm: A cozy ranch layout with a warm, inviting vibe, surrounded by unique homes.Tastefully updated kitchen with new appliances, full bath, wood floors throughout. The Ultimate Bonus Space: A detached garage partially finished with cedar siding, fully framed, with windows, French, sliding glass doors, windows, skylight, and rough plumbing already in place. Perfect for a home office, art studio, or outside pool house. Full Basement: Length of House: Sliding Glass Doors Off Back of House leading to Oversize Wood Decking Full Attic: Length of House: Pull Down Stairs; "A" Shape Roof Line; Window Location, Situated in East Islip School District, Close to Fire Island Ferries and Islip Town Beach Parks, LIRR commute to NYC, Shopping, Famous Restaurants, this community has it all! Whether you want to move right in and update over time or expand the footprint to create something spectacular, the possibilities are truly endless. Bring your vision and make this gem your own!

Take the 3D virtual tour →

Listing Information

Listing Updated
09/29/2026
Listed By
Diane M. Milliard · Howard Hanna Coach, 6319285484
MLS#
900208
Source
OneKey MLS
Status
Active

Facts & Features

Location

Community Information

Address
26 Garfield Ave, East Islip, NY 11730
City
East Islip
County
Suffolk
Zip Code
11730

Architecture

Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1
Year Built
1920
Style
Cottage, A-Frame
Construction Materials
Cedar
Building Area
1,320 sq. ft.
Levels
One
Garage
Yes
Garage Spaces
1
Parking Features
Driveway

Features & Amenities

Interior Features
Ceiling Fan(s), Eat-in Kitchen, Storage, Granite Counters, Entrance Foyer, Natural Woodwork
Appliances
Dryer, Dishwasher, Microwave, Convection Oven, Cooktop, Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
Flooring
Hardwood, Ceramic Tile
Patio and Porch
Deck, Porch
Cooling
Wall/Window Unit(s)
Heating
Baseboard

Property Features

Lot Size
0.34 Acres
Lot Features
Level
Water
Public
Sewer
Public Sewer
Utilities
Natural Gas Available, Cable Connected, Natural Gas Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected

Square Footage

Total
864 sq. ft.

Tax & Financial Information

List Price
$640,000
Annual Taxes
$9,165

Schools

52/100
Connetquot Elementary School
Elementary · Grades PK–02 · 1.5 mi
Assigned school for this home
City
Islip Terrace
Students
339
Student body
63% White · 26% Hispanic / Latino · 4% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
30%
Phone
(631) 224-2001
55/100
East Islip Middle School
Middle · Grades 06–08 · 0.9 mi
Assigned school for this home
City
Islip Terrace
Students
758
Student body
65% White · 24% Hispanic / Latino · 4% Black
Free/reduced lunch
29%
Phone
(631) 224-2008
53/100
East Islip High School
High · Grades 09–12 · 0.9 mi
Assigned school for this home
City
Islip Terrace
Students
1,178
Student body
66% White · 24% Hispanic / Latino · 4% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
28%
Phone
(631) 224-2006
76/100
Ruth C Kinney Elementary School
Elementary · Grades 03–05 · 1.1 mi
City
Islip Terrace
Students
316
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
61% White · 25% Hispanic / Latino · 5% Asian
Free/reduced lunch
25%
Phone
(631) 224-2007
75/100
Maud S Sherwood Elementary School
Elementary · Grades 02–05 · 1.8 mi
City
Islip
Students
315
Parent reviews
5.0★ avg · 2 reviews
Student body
72% White · 17% Hispanic / Latino · 7% Black
Free/reduced lunch
24%
Phone
(631) 650-8650
55/100
Islip Middle School
Middle · Grades 06–08 · 1.7 mi
City
Islip
Students
662
Student body
52% White · 33% Hispanic / Latino · 6% Black
Free/reduced lunch
36%
Phone
(631) 650-8500
55/100
Southeast Elementary School
Elementary · Grades 01–05 · 2.6 mi
City
Brentwood
Students
566
Student body
89% Hispanic / Latino · 7% Black · 2% White
Free/reduced lunch
87%
Phone
(631) 434-2265
55/100
Brook Avenue Elementary School
Elementary · Grades KG–02 · 2.8 mi
City
Bay Shore
Students
336
Student body
62% Hispanic / Latino · 22% White · 10% Black
Free/reduced lunch
42%
Phone
(631) 968-1130

School ratings are provided for informational purposes only and are subject to change. Attendance boundaries are for reference only — contact the school or district directly to verify enrollment eligibility.

Historical Data

Price History

DateEventPrice
06/03/2026Listed for sale$640,000

Listed by Diane M. Milliard · Howard Hanna Coach · 6319285484

Listing information provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed by the MLS. The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed. Copyright 2026, OneKey MLS. All rights reserved.

Last Updated: September 29, 2026 at 7:13 AM | Source: OneKey MLS | MLS#: 900208

Let's work together

Start Your Real Estate Journey

Whether you have questions about this listing, want to schedule a showing, or just want to talk through your options, James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.

How can I help?

James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.

Lending calculator

Make A Plan For Your Purchase

Know what you can afford before you start shopping — then run the numbers on any home you have in mind.

How much house can I afford?

$500,000
You can afford
$0
Monthly payment
  • Principal & interest
  • Property taxes
  • Homeowner's insurance
  • HOA dues

Enter your income, debts, and down payment to see how much home you may qualify for. Estimates only — not a lending decision.

Want to know more?

James Haydon is here to help. Reach out and expect a response within one business day.